Tom Spurgeon's Web site of comics news, reviews, interviews and commentary














July 25, 2016


Go, Read: Abraham Riesman Talks To Bruce Timm About Material In Killing Joke Adaptation

imageI don't have a ton to say about how corporate-property cartoons explore issues touching on sex and violence because I assume they'll do so in a crass way, be strongly criticized for it and then make money anyway.

I am interested that anyone would feel compelled to adapt The Killing Joke, which was to serious graphic novels of the 1980s what "Runaway Train" was to the grunge music era: the successful project that made people stop and wonder if things hadn't ended about a half-year earlier. It's a work the project's writer admitted was deeply limited and problematic. Because they're using the DC standard cartoon approach, you lose 80 percent of Brian Bolland's contributions. And because you're rewriting and expanding it, you stand a pretty good chance of losing a big chunk of craft that Alan Moore might bring as a writer. What you're left with is the idea that a Batman story can handle these delicate issues in the course of doing what it usually does. I think in this case at least, we'll learn it can't.
 
posted 7:55 am PST | Permalink
 

 
Daily Blog Archives
October 2019
September 2019
August 2019
July 2019
June 2019
 
Full Archives