Tom Spurgeon's Web site of comics news, reviews, interviews and commentary















Home > Collective Memories

Critical Consensus -- 2005
posted November 1, 2005
 

Below is a list of major releases from 2005 along with links to reviews of that work. If you have reviewed any of the specific works already listed, and I'll do my best to add it. I will try to update this list once a week.

*****

image

Best of 2005 Lists
Andrew Arnold at Time.comix
Buzzscope.com
Christopher Mautner
Comic Book Galaxy
David Carter
Derik A. Badman
Guy LeCharles Gonzalez
Jog the Blog
John Martz
Love Manga
Marc Mason
Matt Dembicki
Rob Clough
Sean T. Collins
Shawn Hoke
TCJ.com Message Board
Wil Moss



*****

image

Black Hole, Charles Burns, Pantheon, 368 pages, HC, $24.95, 037542380X

BadLit
Boston Globe
Comic Book Galaxy
Giant Magazine
New York Press
Paul Gravett
Salon (Douglas Wolk)
SF Weekly
Time.com
Washington Post (Ben Schwartz)



*****

image

Infinite Crisis #1-7, Geoff Johns and Phil Jimenez, a series of 32-page comics, DC, $2.95

Issue #1
Spatula Forum
PopCultureShock
Photon Torpedoes
Spandex Justice
Luthor's Story of a World Gone Retarded
Sleep Is For Suckers
The Ending to Issue #1, Spoiled in Spanish
Comics Ate My Brain



*****

image

The Quitter, Harvey Pekar and Dean Haspiel, DC, 104 pages, HC, $19.99, 140120399X

The Anchor
Comic Book Galaxy
Denver Post
IGN
Miami Herald
Nashville City Paper
Newsday
Newsarama
PopCultureShock
Rob Clough
Silver Bullet Comics
Snap Judgments
The Daily Cardinal
Village Voice
Vito Delsante



*****

image

Salamander Dream, Hope Larson, AdHouse, 104 pages, SC, 0972179496

Columbusalive.com
Comics Reporter
Comic World News
ComixFan.com
CrisisBoringChange
Peiratikos.net



*****

image

Tricked, Alex Robinson, Top Shelf, 320 pages, SC, 1891830732


Alan David Doane
Crisis/Boring Change
Time.com (Andrew Arnold)



*****

image

Wimbledon Green, Seth, Drawn and Quarterly, 128 pages, HC, 1896597939

Globe and Mail



*****
image

The Secret Voice #1, Zack Soto, AdHouse Books

Chapel Hill Comics
Chris Butcher
Columbus Alive
Comic World News
Eliot Johnson
Jog
Optical Sloth
Silver Bullet Comic Books

*****
*****