Tom Spurgeon's Web site of comics news, reviews, interviews and commentary














September 23, 2007


FfF Results Post #92 -- IndyHeroes

Five For Friday #92 Results
On Friday afternoon, participating CR readers were asked to name "Five Superheroes You Like, a) Created After 1950, b) Not Published By DC or Marvel or Image." Here are the results.

*****

image

Tom Spurgeon
1. E-Man
2. S*perm*n
3. Zot!
4. The Badger
5. Death Ray

*****

imageCharles Brownstein
1) Megaton Man
Don Simpson's megalout is loaded with fun satirical commentary on both comics history and the Reagan 80s in which it first appeared. It's a shame this book is largely out of print.
2) Death Ray
Sorry to do a repeat, but as an avid smoker, how can I not love a character whose powers come from nicotine?
3) The One
This early revisionist superhero was a wonderful apotheosis of burnt out hippy idealism, ascending 80s commercialism, and the budding wholesale sportfucking that the superhero genre was about to engage in after losing its innocence in the 70s.
4) Wonder Warthog
I have no idea if this holds up, but I sure loved it when I was in college. Shelton's drawings are always a pleasure and the sheer absurdity of this character,in its visual design and in its cultural and comic art historical contexts are so retarded that they're endearing.
5) The Roach
Maybe the most "Inside Baseball" character in comics history. Sim's permutations on the Roach -- Moon Roach, Wolverroach, Spider-Roach, normalroach, Swoon, et al. are simultaneously a fun commentary on the excesses of the Direct Market's content from 1977 - 1997 (which I consider to be the entirety of that business cycle) and, unfortunately, the biggest stumbling block towards a casual reader of the modern era engaging fully with Cerebus in its prime. Still, if you get it, the in-jokes are still entertaining.

*****

Chris Duffy
1. Flaming Carrot
2. Superfrankenstein
3. Nexus
4. Hellboy
5. Fatman the Human Flying Saucer

*****

imageDave Knott
1) Nexus
Does this even count? It's really more of a space opera in superhero trappings. Doesn't matter. I had to put a Steve Rude comic in here.
2) Hellboy
See above. In this case, its more of a monster-fighting adventure dressed up as superhero comics, but you gotta give Mike Mignola his props.
3) The Question
Steve Ditko's greatest non-Marvel work. Currently owed by DC, of course, but so is E-Man from your list, so we'll let it slide.
4) Marvel-man / Miracle-man
Yes, this started out as an outright clone of Captain Marvel in the early 50's, but as (re-)interpreted by Moore, Gaiman, & Co. in the '80s, it outgrew it's origins and became a modern-day classic.
5) Grendel
The best anti-hero of the last quarter-century

*****

Marc Arsenault
1. Captain Spazz
Bobby Weiss & Sam Henderson (went to school with the artist)
2. Captain Canuck
the George Freeman issues (I actually read this as a kid!)
3. Mighty Samson
Gold Key (he's a super strong mutant, so he counts!) (I also actually read this as a kid!)
4. Captain Atom
(Joe Gill & Steve Ditko) (kid... read... also)
5. Magnus Fucking Robot Fighter!
(Steve Bissette got me hooked on this)

*****

imageIsaac Cates
1. Concrete
2. The Death Ray
3. Convenient Boy and the Power of 6
4. Ace Face, the Mod with the Metal Arms
5. Billy Dogma

*****

Todd Strending
1. Mr. A.
2. The American
3. Zot!, too
4. Ropeman from The Mighty Heroes
5. The Cougar

*****

imageMike Sterling
1. Nexus
2. Don Rosa's Captain Kentucky
3. Megaton Man
4. Flaming Carrot
5. Zot!

*****

Patrick Watson
1. Nexus
2. Usagi Yojimbo
3. Concrete
4. Hellboy
5. The David Yurkovich-verse

*****

imageCliff Biggers
1. Noman
2. Herbie
3. Magnus, Robot Fighter
4. Dynamo
5. E-Man

*****

Don MacPherson
1) Prime (now owned by Marvel by originally published by Malibu Comics)
2) Quantum & Woody
3) Hellboy
4) Captain Canuck
5) The Blue Falcon & Dynomutt

*****

imageRuss Maheras
Dynamo
Capt. Atom
The Question
Magnus
Rocketeer

*****

Johnny Bacardi
1. The Rocketeer (Pacific, Eclipse, god knows who else)
2. The Scorpion (Atlas) (I guess he qualifies as a superhero...)
3. Magnus, Robot Fighter (Gold Key)
4. Dr. Solar, Man of the Atom (Gold Key)
5. Why, Hellboy! (Dark Horse)

*****

imageScott Cederlund
1) Grendel
2) Zot!
3) Grimjack
4) Nexus
5) Vanth Dreadstar (hey, he had a superhero costume for a short bit)

*****

Matthewwave
1. Concrete! (he's a hero to me!)
2. Frank the Unicorn! (ditto!)
3. Jetcat!
4. Orange Lightning!
5. Bighead!

*****

imageJeff Shinn
1.Nexus/Rude &Baron
2.Madman/Allred
3.Mage/Wagner
4.Powers/Bendis&Oeming
5.Badger/Butler, Reinhold & Baron

*****

Sean T. Collins
1. The Death Ray
2. Hellboy
3. David Dunn (from Unbreakable)
4. Luna Moth
5. Bighead

*****

imageMark Parsons
1) Promethea
2) Hellboy
3) Grimjack
4) Zot!
5) Nexus

*****

Gil Roth
1. Acid Archie
C'mon, an acid house robot?
2. Megaton Man
the first indy I ever read, it had a Doonesbury joke that I didn't understand
3. Miracle Man
the second indy I ever read; it was much better than the first one
4. Zenith
I've always been a sucker for mix-n-match cultural refs; sue me
5. Rogan Gosh
I couldn't think of anything else, except for Tank Girl

*****
Five For Friday is a reader response feature. To play, send a response to that week's question a) while it's still Friday, b) that doesn't try to twist or avoid the spirit of the exercise. Responses up by Monday morning.
 
posted 6:10 am PST | Permalink
 

 
Daily Blog Archives
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
 
Full Archives