May 15, 2011
FFF Results Post #254—Non-Conventional Wisdom
On Friday,
CR readers were asked to "Take A Creator. Name A Work Considered A Or Even
The Great Work By That Creator And Put It In The #5 Slot. Name Four Works You Suspect May Be Better And Put Them In The #1-4 Slots." This is how they responded.
Tom Spurgeon
1. "Pictopia"
2. "The Anatomy Lesson"
3.
V For Vendetta
4.
From Hell
5.
Watchmen
*****
Dave Knott
1)
Monkeyman & O'Brien
2)
Godzilla
3)
Jonni Future
4)
Gumby
5)
Longshot
*****
Jason Green
1.
Next Men
2.
Namor
3.
Babe
4.
Man of Steel
5.
Uncanny X-Men
*****
Michael Grabowski
1.
Daredevil: Born Again (#227-233)
2.
Daredevil #168-181
3.
Elektra: Assassin
4.
Batman: Year One
5.
The Dark Knight Returns
*****
Scott Cederlund
1)
Invisibles Volume Three #1
2)
New X-Men: For Tomorrow
3)
Animal Man #5
4)
The Filth
5)
WE3
*****
Michael Dooley
1.
Young Allies
2.
Boy Commandos
3.
Young Romance
4.
Justice Traps the Guilty
5.
Incredible Hulk
*****
Grant Goggans
1.
Doctor Who
2.
Legion of Super-Heroes: "There's This Girl"
3.
Dan Dare
4.
Ro-Busters: "The Terra-Meks"
5.
Watchmen
*****
Shannon Smith
1.
The Invisibles
2.
Flex Mentallo
3.
The Filth
4.
Animal Man
5.
All-Star Superman
*****
Douglas Wolk
1.
Doctor Strange #48-53
2.
Cap'n Quick & A Foozle #1-2
3.
Madame Xanadu #1
4. "Death Strikes at Midnight and Three" in
DC Special Series #15
5.
Detective Comics #475-476
*****
Buzz Dixon
1. "My World" (
Weird Science #22)
2. "The Comic Strip Characters' Christmas Party" (
Mad #68)
3. "Julius Caesar!" (
Mad #17)
4.
Cannon
5.
T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents
*****
Robin McConnell
1.
I Never Liked You
2.
Showing Helder
3.
Paying For It
4.
Apostles
5.
Playboy
*****
Justin J. Major
1. "Philippe is standing on it"
2. "Lie Bot, what is the saddest thing?"
3. Orange creamsicle alcohol drink (the drink, not the strip)
4. "Ray's Place"
5.
The Great Outdoor Fight
*****
Gavin Lees
1.
We3
2.
Flex Mentallo
3.
The New Adventures of Hitler
4.
The Filth
5.
The Invisibles
*****
Scott Dunbier
1)
You Are Here
2)
Cowboy Wally
3) "Leticia Lerner, Superman's Babysitter"
4)
Plastic Man
5)
Why I Hate Saturn
*****
Max Fischer
1.
Thirteen (Going On Eighteen)
2.
Kookie
3.
Melvin Monster
4.
Bridget And Her Little Brother Newton The Nuisance
5.
Little Lulu
*****
Danny Ceballos
1.
Doom Patrol
2.
Animal Man
3.
St. Swithin's Day
4.
The Invisibles
5.
All-Star Superman
*****
Chad Nevett
1.
Wildcats Volume Two
2.
Automatic Kafka
3.
Codeflesh
4.
Adventures of Superman #613-624
5.
Wildcats Version 3.0
*****
Sean T. Collins
1. "Browntown"
2. "Flies on the Ceiling"
3. "Tear It Up, Terry Downe"
4. "A Date with Hopey"
5.
Ghost of Hoppers
*****
Des Devlin
* "Four Freedoms"
* "Breaking Home Ties"
* "After the Prom"
* "Elect Casey"
* "The Chars"
(I think Mr. Devlin meant for "Four Freedoms" to go in the #5 slot; I can't tell)
*****
Ben Ostrander
1.
Blueberry
2.
The Airtight Garage
3.
Madwoman of the Sacred Heart
4.
Arzach
5.
The Incal
*****
Mark Coale
1.
Manhunter
2.
Thrilling Adventures
3.
Fantastic Four
4.
1st Issue Special
5.
Thor
*****
Thomas Scioli
1.
The Forever People
2.
Eternals
3.
Thor
4.
Captain Victory
5.
Fantastic Four
*****
Joe Keatinge
1.
Hip Flask
2.
Spider-Boy Team Up
3.
Cable
4.
Superman: Transilvane
5.
Final Incal
*****
Matt Maxwell
1.
Elektra: Assassin
2.
Ronin
3.
Batman: Year One
4.
Sin City (The Hard Goodbye)
5.
The Dark Knight Returns
*****
Stergios Botzakis, Ph.D
1.
Daredevil: Born Again
2.
Batman Year One
3.
Daredevil #191
4.
That Yellow Bastard
5.
The Dark Knight Returns
*****
Stergios Botzakis, Ph.D
1.
The Question
2.
The Shadow
3.
Batman
4.
Detective Comics
5.
Green Lantern/Green Arrow
*****
topic altered from a suggestion by Matthew Badham; thank you, Matthew
*****
*****
posted 1:00 am PST |
Permalink
Daily Blog Archives
November 2019
October 2019
September 2019
August 2019
July 2019
Full Archives
