FFF Results Post #350—Four Different Faces

On Friday, CR readers were asked to "Name Four Different Comics Versions You Like Of The Same Character And In #5 Name The Character." This is how they responded.



Tom Spurgeon

1. The Original Siegel/Shuster
2. The Mindy Newell/Gray Morrow Mini-Series
3. Darwyn Cooke's In New Frontier
4. Any Time She's Drawn By Kurt Schaffenberger
5. Lois Lane

*****



Mike Buntag

1. Otto Binder/Marc Swayze's original series
2. Keith Giffen/J.M. DeMatteis and Kevin Maguire's Formerly Known As The Justice League
3. Dylan Horrocks/Jessica Abel's story in Bizarro Comics
4. Jeff Smith's Shazam!: The Monster Society of Evil
5. Mary Batson/Mary Marvel

*****



Tim O'Neil

1. Lee & Kirby's cosmic naif
2. Lee & Buscema's noble depressive
3. Englehart & Rogers' mature idealist
4. Starlin & Lim's remorseful warrior
5. The SIlver Surfer!

*****



Steve Replogle

1. Jerry Siegel's King of Crooks
2. Paul Grist's A. Chinard, always fooling Jack Staff
3. Stealing Mytek the MIghty, in Alan Moore's Albion
4. Jacques Tardi's ghostly cameo, from West Coast Blues
5. The Spider

*****



Justin Colussy-Estes

1. Jerry Scott
2. Ernie Bushmiller, of course
3. John Stanley
4. Ivan Brunetti (almost?)
5. Nancy

*****



Jeffrey O. Gustafson

1. Jack Kirby and Joe Sinnott's
2. Mike Wieringo's
3. Stuart Immonen's
4. Mike McKone's
5. Ben Grimm

*****



Don MacPherson

1. The Golden Age version, tinged with bondage elements
2. George Perez's 1980s revamp
3. Azzarello/Chiang's New 52 redo
4. Greg Rucka's fierce, practical warrior woman
5. Wonder Woman

*****



Jonathan Baylis

* The original Jack Kirby
* John Byrne's later on.
* John Romita/Joe Sinnott's on the cover of Marvel Age
* Dean Haspiel's Night Falls on Yancy Street
* The Thing

*****



Johnny Bacardi

1. Bernard Baily's original
2. Neal Adams' 60's version
3. Jerry Grandenetti's continuation of same
4. Jim Aparo's crazy-ass 70's version
5. The Spectre!

*****



Matt Emery

1. Sy Barry dailies reprinted in Australian Frew comics
2. Jim Aparo working for Charlton Comics
3. Alex Saviuk on Defenders of the Earth for Marvel
4. Steve Ditko on 2040 version for Marvel
5. The Phantom

*****



Buzz Dixon

1. Sly & sexy Bob Montana version
2. Cute & playful Dan DeCarlo version
3. Gender-bender version by Tania del Rio & Gisele Lagace
4. Bat-shit crazy version in scripts written by Frank Doyle (http://eepomigosh.blogspot.com/2009/09/archie-143-strike-up-band-kisser.html#kisserstrikes )
5. Betty Cooper

*****



Kiel Phegley

1. Jack Kirby's original
2. Walt Simonson's Orion redesign
3. Morrison/Porter/Dell's future version from JLA
4. Those largely uncredited Super Powers mini comics
5. Darkseid

*****



Sean Kleefeld

1. By Lee/Kirby/Sinnott
2. By John Byrne
3. By Slott/DiVito
4. By Walt Simonson
5. The Thing

*****



Michael Dooley

1. Jess's Tricky Cad
3. Feldstein and Elder's Tick Dracy
2. Gilbert Shelton's Tricky Prickears
4. Al Capp's Fearless Fosdick ads for Wildroot
5. Dick Tracy

*****



Sean T. Collins

* Frank Miller
* Grant Morrison/Tony Daniel
* Ed Pinsent
* Josh Simmons
* Batman

*****



Tom Bondurant

1. Post-Silver Age version, as written by Cary Bates and drawn by Irv Novick et al.
2. In flashback stories written by Mark Waid and drawn by Barry Kitson in JLA: Year One and Flash & Green Lantern: The Brave and the Bold
3. Funky-timeline version, as written by Kurt Busiek and drawn by George Perez in JLA/Avengers
4. New-52 version, written and drawn by Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato
5. Barry Allen/The Flash

*****



Jamie Coville

1. Original Jack Kirby
2. Walter Simonson run
3. John Buscema/Tom Palmer in Avengers, particularly the cover of issue #276
4. John Romita, Jr./Klaus Janson that kicked off Volume 2 of his series.
5. Thor

*****



Joshua Leto

1. Steve Ditko
2. John Romita
3. Gil Kane
4. Mike Zeck
5. Kraven the Hunter

*****



Matthew Craig

1. The Original John Romita chimple and dimples; gogo dancer extraordinaire.
2. Roger Stern/Tom DeFalco/Ron Frenz's vulnerable but self-reliant best friend.
3. Sal Buscema's big-haired, big-hearted newlywed, who took a baseball bat to the Chameleon without so much as a broken nail.
4. Brian Michael Bendis/Sara Pichelli's painfully hip adorkagoth.
5. Mary Jane Watson/Watson-Parker

*****



Mark Mayerson

1. Carl Barks
2. Walt Kelly
3. Don Rosa
4. Daan Jippes
5. Donald Duck

*****



Steve Murphy

1. The Herb Trimpe (pencils)/John Severin (inks) iteration in Incredible Hulk #109 (1968)
2. Barry Smith (pencils)/Bill Everett (inks) from Astonishing Tales #6 (1971)
3. Anything from Savage Tales magazine (c. mid-1970s)
4. The Bruce Jones (writer)/Brent Anderson (penciler) run (early 1980s)
5. Ka-Zar and Zabu

*****



Oliver Ristau

1) Michael Fleisher/Jim Aparo's gruesome run in Adventure Comics
2) John Ostrander/Tom Mandrake's examination of the problems of morals and ethics
3) Doug Moench/Chris Wozniak smart private eye version
4) John Marc DeMatteis/Ryan Sook's version without Jim Corrigan
5) The Spectre

*****



John Vest

1. Steve Ditko's original stories
2. Gene Colan's late sixties version of the character in his own title
3. Tom Sutton's mid-seventies run
4. P Craig Russell's one-shot in the nineties
5. Doctor Strange

*****



Scott Dunbier

* The First Appearance -- Simon & Kirby
* The Reappearance -- Kirby
* The Death of -- Steranko
* Back to Basics -- Byrne
* Captain America

*****



Andrew Mansell

1. My Greatest Adventure era by Bruno Premiani
2. Joe Staton's from Showcase
3. Richard Case
4. John Byrne's
5. Doom Patrol

*****

Please note: I do these results post the first chance I get after Friday. That means if you send your work in later than Friday 11:59 PM, there's a chance I won't be at the computer from the time I advance post the results Saturday AM until Monday AM. I'm not angry at you: I simply haven't seen your response because I'm out doing something else. Sorry about that, but, you know, weekend.

*****

This feature will return in two weeks -- I'm taking SPX weekend off. Probably.

*****
*****
 
posted 4:00 pm PST | Permalink
 

---

 
Daily Blog Archives
November 2019
October 2019
September 2019
August 2019
July 2019
 
Full Archives